Condo Right of First Refusal: It’s Not a Rejection Tool
Back to the NYC Real Estate Blog
A condo right of first refusal lets the board buy your unit itself, at the same price and terms you already agreed to, typically within 30 days of notice. It’s a purchase right, not a rejection tool: a condo board can’t simply decline a buyer the way a co-op board can.
The board can only say no by buying you out.
What a condo right of first refusal actually does, versus a co-op right of first refusal
Nearly every NYC condo’s bylaws include a right of first refusal clause. It’s one of the most commonly misunderstood provisions in condo ownership.
Here’s the mechanism, correctly. Once you have a signed contract with a buyer, your board gets a window to match those exact terms. It can purchase the unit itself instead of letting your sale proceed.
“A condo right of first refusal is a purchase right, while co-op board approval is a consent process,” says Benjamin Taylor, a licensed real estate agent at Highline Residential. Hauseit’s own guidance confirms the same point independently: “Unlike a co-op board, a condo board does not have the power to reject you for any reason.”
That’s a meaningful distinction from how a co-op board operates. A co-op board can decline your buyer’s application without buying anything and without stating a reason. A condo board exercising ROFR has to put its own money where its objection is, on the exact terms you already agreed to.
Why a condo board waives right of first refusal so often
Raising real money on a deadline is the hard part. Exercising a right of first refusal means the condo association has to come up with the full purchase price on short notice. It then has to own the unit and eventually resell it.
That’s a real financial and logistical lift for most condo boards. It also risks real friction with the seller, with other unit owners, and with the buyer who was ready to close.
In practice, boards use ROFR sparingly. When they do, it’s usually for a specific reason: a sale price so far below market it would drag down comps for everyone else in the building. Or the board wants the unit for a superintendent, or to convert it into common space. Far more often, the board simply waives its right and lets the sale proceed as planned.
| Right of first refusal | Co-op board approval |
|---|---|
| A purchase right, exercised by buying the unit | A consent process, no purchase required to decline |
| Set in the building’s declaration/bylaws | Set in the proprietary lease and house rules |
| Board rarely exercises it, waives it instead | Board decides case by case, can reject without a stated reason |
Where right of first refusal nyc real estate law actually comes from
Your building’s own bylaws, not a citywide clock. A condo’s right of first refusal isn’t created by a standalone New York statute. It’s a contractual provision written into the specific condominium’s declaration and bylaws. Those are part of the offering plan, filed with and reviewed by the New York Attorney General’s Real Estate Finance Bureau under 13 NYCRR Part 23.
That means the exact deadline isn’t universal either. Thirty days is the common, customary window found in most sample bylaw language. It’s not guaranteed, though; at least one sample clause we found specifies 45 days instead.
Some buildings structure it more granularly. That can mean paperwork within 10 business days of a formal notice, with closing adjourned up to 30 business days while the board decides. Read your specific building’s bylaws rather than assuming the common 30-day figure applies.
If you’re weighing a purchase and want the real closing-cost picture regardless of this clause, run your numbers with NestApple’s closing costs calculator.
Condo board rejection buyer discrimination: the one thing ROFR can’t be used for
Rejecting someone the board simply doesn’t like. A board can’t invoke a right of first refusal, or any other mechanism, to discriminate against a buyer on protected-class grounds. The NYC Human Rights Law and the New York State Human Rights Law both generally prohibit housing discrimination. That backstop applies here the same way it does in any other real estate transaction.
Co-ops, by contrast, generally use board discretion rather than a right of first refusal to control who buys in. Our co-op costs and rules hub covers other co-op-specific costs and rules that don’t apply the same way to a condo purchase.
If you’re deciding between a co-op and a condo, that control question is worth weighing early. It’s a real, structural difference. If you’re buying with NestApple, our buyer rebate can offset part of what the purchase costs, condo or co-op.
Common questions
Can a condo board reject a buyer using its right of first refusal? No. Exercising ROFR requires the board to actually purchase the unit on the same terms. It can’t simply decline a buyer and walk away, as a co-op board can.
How long does a condo board have to exercise its right of first refusal? Commonly about 30 days, but it’s not universal. Some buildings’ bylaws specify a different window; read your specific building’s declaration and bylaws rather than assuming 30 days.
Do co-ops have a right of first refusal too? Co-ops more commonly rely on board discretion and consent, a legally different process from a condo’s purchase-based right of first refusal.
Where is a condo’s right of first refusal written down? In the building’s own declaration and bylaws, part of the offering plan filed with the NY Attorney General’s Real Estate Finance Bureau, not a standalone state statute.
Why do condo boards rarely exercise their right of first refusal? Because exercising it means the board must raise and pay the full purchase price itself, a real financial commitment most boards choose to waive instead.
Nicole Fishman Benoliel co-founded NestApple in 2017. She's a lawyer admitted to the New York bar - her law degree is from La Escuela Libre de Derecho in Costa Rica, with further study at IE Business School in Madrid and an LLM from Fordham in New York. She does not act in a legal capacity at NestApple; every client is referred to an attorney who handles real estate deals full time.
