Real Estate Agent Rebate: How Much and How It’s Paid
Back to the NYC Real Estate Blog
A real estate agent rebate is part of the buyer-side commission, returned to you. The seller still pays the full commission. Your agent keeps a working share and gives back the rest, often 25% to 75% of the buy-side fee, as a closing credit or a later check. It’s legal in about 40 states.
The rebate is our whole model. We’ve returned more than $11 million to buyers since 2017, an average of about $22,000 per closing.
The short version: the buyer’s agent kept a working share and handed you the rest.
| Typical rebate brokerage | NestApple | |
|---|---|---|
| What comes back | 25% to 75% of the buy-side commission | Up to 2% of the purchase price |
| How it’s paid | Closing credit or post-closing check | Disclosed in the agreement, credited or paid at closing |
| Reported average | ~$23,000 to $24,000 (their own data) | ~$22,000 (our own data) |
What is a real estate agent rebate?
It’s a share of your agent’s commission, returned to you. On a resale, the seller pays a total commission that covers both sides. Your agent’s brokerage receives the buy-side portion, then rebates part of it to you.
New York law allows this directly. Real Property Law section 442 lets a broker give “any part of a fee, commission, or other compensation” to the buyer. Whether it’s allowed where you’re buying is covered on our page on commission rebates and their legality.
The rebate doesn’t reduce your service. It’s a share of a fee that the market keeps high, handed to the person who did the searching. What NestApple returns to buyers is one version of it.
How much is a real estate rebate?
A share of a fee that’s already a percentage of a big number, so it adds up fast. The buy-side commission averages about 2.5% of the price today. A rebate of half that on a $1 million home is around $12,500.
Rebate brokerages return anywhere from a quarter to nearly all of the buy-side fee. Yoreevo reports an average of around $24,000 across its deals; Prevu reports about $23,000. Those are their own figures. Ours run about $22,000, more than $11 million since 2017.
The exact amount depends on the price, what the seller offers the buy side, and the share specified in your agreement.
How does a real estate rebate work at closing?
Two ways. A credit on the closing statement, or a check that shows up like a birthday card a week or two after.
- A closing credit. The rebate appears as a credit to you on the Closing Disclosure, with the paying party named. Your lender’s underwriter has to approve it. Lenders usually apply it to closing costs rather than the down payment, and total credits can’t exceed your actual closing costs.
- A post-closing check. Your brokerage receives its commission, then writes you a check for your share. This is common when the rebate exceeds your closing costs.
Either way, it’s disclosed to the lender and shown in writing. Our closing-cost calculators let you model a deal with the rebate applied.
Is a real estate agent rebate taxable?
No. The IRS calls it a discount, and discounts don’t come with a W-2. In Private Letter Ruling 200721013, the IRS held that a rebate “represents an adjustment to the purchase price of the home and generally is not includible in a purchaser’s gross income.”
No 1099 is issued. The rebate reduces your cost basis in the home, which can increase your capital gain if you sell later, though the federal home-sale exclusion usually covers it.
How to negotiate a real estate rebate
Ask before the first showing, not at the closing table. By then, your agent’s fee is set, and there’s nothing to give back.
- Raise it early. A rebate is easiest to agree on when you’re choosing an agent, not after.
- Expect an exclusive agreement. Most rebate brokers ask for one in exchange, which is a fair trade.
- Get it in writing. The share should be a line in your buyer agency agreement, not a promise.
- Confirm the lender is fine with it. A quick call avoids a surprise on the Closing Disclosure.
This page is part of our guide to NYC commissions and rebates.
What we pay
The airport offers twenty-two thousand dollars at a time. The company started when Nicole rebated a full commission to a few buyers who asked, and Georges saw a business in it.
Now it’s a stated share in every agreement. On a $1 million deal at 3% to the buy side, in Georges’s words, “from those 30k we keep 10, we give back 20.” See what NestApple returns to buyers for the current terms.
Common questions
How much is a typical real estate agent rebate? Commonly, 25% to 75% of the buy-side commission. On a $1 million home, that’s often $6,000 to $18,000. Rebate brokerages report averages around $22,000 to $24,000.
How is the rebate paid? As a credit on your closing statement, or a check a week or two after closing. Both are disclosed to your lender.
Is a real estate rebate taxable income? No. The IRS treats it as a reduction in the purchase price, so there’s no 1099. It lowers your cost basis in the home.
Can I get a rebate and still have a real agent? Yes. The seller pays the full commission either way. A rebate broker keeps a working share and returns the rest, with full representation.
Nicole Fishman Benoliel co-founded NestApple in 2017. She's a lawyer admitted to the New York bar - her law degree is from La Escuela Libre de Derecho in Costa Rica, with further study at IE Business School in Madrid and an LLM from Fordham in New York. She does not act in a legal capacity at NestApple; every client is referred to an attorney who handles real estate deals full time.
