Income Potential in the Heart of Lake Huntington
Discover the possibilities at this unique two-unit property offering flexibility and income potential in the Sullivan Catskills.
The property is being offered with an existing tenant in place under a lease scheduled through **September 30, 2027**, providing the next owner with established rental income from the start. This makes it an appealing opportunity for investors or buyers looking to add an income-producing property to their real estate portfolio.
Each unit offers its own private living space, providing separation and independence between occupants. The property also features a two-car garage, sits on approximately one acre, and includes an **unfinished basement offering additional space and future potential for storage, a workshop, or finishing and updating to suit the next owner’s needs, subject to applicable approvals and requirements.**
Located in the desirable Lake Huntington area, the property is convenient to outdoor recreation, lakes, dining, shopping, and the many attractions that make Sullivan County a sought-after destination.
For buyers looking beyond a traditional single-family home, this property offers versatility, rental income potential, additional space to improve over time, and the opportunity to build long-term equity through real estate ownership.
Schedule your showing today and explore what this Lake Huntington property has to offer.
Delightfully renovated, year round charming Cottage on three quarters of an acre in a lovely central location to all of Sullivan County. Natural light fills the home and warmth and coziness from the fireplace for cooler evenings takes the chill out while relaxing with your loved ones. This home has been a wonderful short term rental, while also having been enjoyed by the owners. Fire pit and swing chairs in the ample back yard enhance the ambiance and your tranquil experiences at this very attractive and updated place in the country! Move in ready. Furniture may be included. Don’t miss your chance to have a fully remodeled home in the Country!
Charming 1942 Cape Cod nestled on 8.42 private acres along a quiet dead-end road in Cochecton, This inviting home features a kitchen, dining room, comfortable living room, two bedrooms, a convenient mudroom, laundry room, deck, and a versatile bonus room ideal for a home office, studio, or guest space.
Enjoy peaceful country living with easy access to some of the area’s most desirable destinations—just about 10 minutes from Bethel Woods and within convenient reach of Jeffersonville, Narrowsburg, and Callicoon, known for their quaint downtowns, local restaurants, shops, and community charm. Nearby lakes and the Delaware River offer plenty of opportunities for swimming, boating, fishing, kayaking, and enjoying the outdoors.
Whether you’re looking for a weekend retreat, a work-from-home escape, or a full-time country home call to schedule a visit.
It’s rare to find a turnkey Catskills property with this much breathing room. Surrounded by rolling fields and historic barns, this home is ready as-is, but has the space and opportunity needed to embody your vision; whether that’s a compound shared with loved ones, a creative retreat, or a working homestead. Odell Farmhouse allows you to start enjoying the property from day one.
It’s hard to pick a favorite moment here – this historic property oozes warmth and understated elegance out of every corner. You can still feel the echoes of the past inside its walls. The wide plank floors and original woodwork reflect a legacy of loving care. The house has a pleasant and natural flow, with generously sized rooms, high ceilings, and an abundance of natural light.
A spacious informal entryway is anchored by a large cast iron stove and a delightfully surprising wood fired oven perfect for pizza nights and bread baking and features a convenient powder room with laundry. From here, the kitchen, with modern appliances and a vintage feel, opens into a cozy sitting area, so the cook needn’t lack for company. At the front of the house, the dining room and parlor are both anchored by french doors that open onto the recently refreshed rocking chair porch and offer lovely views of the surrounding grounds. A formal front entry and staircase reflect genteel elegance in the their original details.
Upstairs are four very spacious bedrooms, each with closet and generous windows framing the idyllic landscape. The full bathroom on this floor leads to a hidden alcove with three additional rooms. Two are insulated spaces over the main house, currently used as a playroom. The third is a rustic workshop area, unheated but with electricity, that connects to a similar space below. The lower level functions as garden shed and also houses the bulk of the wood oven mentioned earlier.
Outside you’ll find two covered porches overlooking mature trees and gardens, including maples, apples, pears, and lilacs. A stone patio extends your outdoor living space and overlooks the charming gazebo, perfect for rainy day meditations or perhaps an ad hoc greenhouse. Several additional outbuildings remain as a nod to the property’s previous life as a working farm. There’s opportunity here for folks with some vision.
Hidden away beyond the back fields lies a secluded pond. Once a favorite private swimming hole (and possible winter skating pond), the idyllic surroundings offer the perfect opportunity to create another destination gathering space on the property. Think cooling summer dips, picnic lunches dockside, and cozy winter bonfires after hiking around your more than thirty private acres.
Don’t let the rural setting fool you – Odell Farmhouse still sits close to an abundance of local attractions. Bethel Woods Center for the Arts is just six minutes away, and features world class musical acts, bustling makers markets and seasonal attractions year round on the site of the original Woodstock Festival. The charming river hamlets of Narrowsburg and Callicoon are both just fifteen minutes away and offer farmer’s markets, excellent shopping, and enticing cultural events that run the gamut from the Deepwater Literary Festival to the annual Tractor Parade. Be sure to check out local favorites The Heron and Black Walnut when you’re in the mood to dine out. And make a night of it with a film at Callicoon Theater and a few frames at the newly reopened bowling alley.
Completed in 2026, this exceptional modern chalet offers a seamless blend of contemporary architecture, energy-efficient construction, and the timeless beauty of the Catskills. Set on more than 6 private acres along a scenic country road in the Town of Narrowsburg, this newly built retreat provides a rare opportunity to enjoy modern luxury surrounded by nature. Designed to maximize natural light and capture the beauty of its surroundings, the home features an open-concept floor plan highlighted by soaring ceilings and walls of windows that flood the interior with sunlight. The spacious living room centers around a beautiful fireplace, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for gathering with family and friends. The thoughtfully designed kitchen features Quartz backsplash and countertops, ample workspace, and a layout that flows effortlessly into the dining and living areas, making it ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. One of the home’s standout features is the expansive wraparound deck, offering the perfect setting to enjoy the surrounding landscape from every angle. Whether hosting outdoor gatherings, dining al fresco, or simply relaxing with a morning coffee, this outdoor living space creates a seamless connection between the home’s interior and the natural beauty that surrounds it. The home offers three generously sized bedrooms and three-and-a-half baths, combining comfort and functionality with modern finishes throughout. Energy-efficient systems, including a tankless hot water heater, provide convenience and long-term savings while complementing the home’s quality construction. The additional 1450 sf finished walkout basement significantly expands the living space and offers endless possibilities, whether used as a recreation room, media room, home office, fitness area, guest quarters, or all of the above. Large windows and direct outdoor access create a bright, welcoming environment that feels fully integrated with the main living areas. Adding to the property’s appeal is a detached two-car garage featuring unfinished space above. Whether you envision a future guest suite, artist’s studio, home office, workshop, fitness room, or additional storage, this flexible space offers tremendous potential to customize and expand according to your needs. Outside, the property is a private sanctuary surrounded by mature trees, native wildlife, and the peaceful sounds of nature. Enjoy morning coffee while watching deer wander through the landscape, evenings beneath star-filled skies, and the serenity that comes with owning over six acres of beautiful Catskill countryside.
Located just minutes from the Delaware River, residents can enjoy world-class fly fishing, kayaking, rafting, hiking, and countless outdoor adventures. Narrowsburg has become one of the Catskills’ most sought-after river towns, celebrated for its vibrant arts scene, charming Main Street, acclaimed restaurants, boutique shops, galleries, farmers markets, and year-round community events. Enjoy performances at the Tusten Theatre, explore local artisan shops, or dine along the river while taking in spectacular views of the Delaware. The surrounding Catskill Mountains provide endless opportunities for recreation, making this an ideal destination for those seeking both relaxation and adventure.
Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or investment property, this remarkable new construction home offers modern comfort, flexible living space, and an unparalleled connection to the natural beauty of the Catskills.
Historic Victorian era Methodist Church, built in 1892 and retaining much of its original ornate detailing, construction and character. The interior features hand-painted tin walls and ceilings, original hand crafted glass chandelier, stained glass windows, original kerosene lamps, two wood-burning stoves and hardwood flooring with original pews, pulpit and furnishings. Distinctive stonework.
The property is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
A separate parish hall offers electricity, heat, a kitchen, and a bathroom. The kitchen and bathroom are not currently in use and requires renovation. The property is serviced by a private well and septic system that is currently not in use.
The church and related improvements are being sold as is, offering a unique opportunity to preserve, restore, and adapt an important piece of local history. Suitable for continued religious use, a community gathering space, event venue, or for the dreamers who have always wanted to renovate an old church into a home! Potential use subject to applicable zoning, approvals, and historic restrictions. Buyer to conduct all due diligence regarding condition, permitted uses, utilities, and renovations.
Charming and well maintained 4 bedroom, 1 bath ranch style home set on almost 3 acres! This inviting home features a bright eat-in kitchen, a comfortable living room, and a cozy reading nook with a window seat-the perfect spot to relax with your favorite book or cup of coffee. The property also includes an office/workshop, offering endless possibilities for working from home, hobbies, or creative projects. Step outside and enjoy a yard that fees like your very own private park! The beautifully maintained grounds are ideal for relaxing or entertaining and feature abundant perennial landscaping, a fruit and vegetable garden, and four storage sheds. Conveniently located just minutes from Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, dining, shopping, casinos, and indoor waterparks, this property offers the perfect combination of peaceful country living with nearby entertainment and amenities. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this charming property your own!
Dreaming of a weekend retreat, vacation getaway, or hunting camp that both you and friends can enjoy? Well, look no further. This 1,144 sq. ft., 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home is set on 66.44 acres, featuring rolling terrain and an almost even blend of hay fields and diverse forest. This property is coming to the market for the first time in the past 40 years.
The home provides a cozy country feel, giving you just about everything that you need and nothing you don’t. The first floor has a living room, an open-concept kitchen with windows overlooking the property, and a door leading to a small private deck, a great spot to enjoy your morning coffee. A third room adjoining the kitchen can be used as an additional dining area. This room is set up with an old-style wood-fired stove and oven, great for an additional heat source on cold nights and providing extra cooking space when entertaining guests. A spacious half bath rounds out the first-floor features.
The second floor features three bedrooms, a full bathroom, and stairs leading to a walk-up attic, providing ample storage space. A 144 sq. ft. enclosed front porch overlooks the property, providing another area to enjoy views of the land while keeping you out of the elements.
A full basement houses the utilities, an oil-fired furnace, and an above-ground oil tank. The home is being sold as-is and fully furnished, allowing you to come and enjoy your new investment on day one of ownership.
Heading outside, there is a 20′ x 28′ two-bay garage, perfect for storage of equipment and toys. Fruit trees can be found throughout the yard area, surrounded by large fields that are currently in hay production and provide an agricultural tax exemption for the property.
The property presents opportunities for hobby farming, homesteading, self-sustainability, and equestrian use, not to mention just about every recreational activity you can think of. For hunting, there is an abundance of game and open areas that would make great locations for food plots. Oak stands provide acorns during mast crop years, along with bedding areas and many great locations for both tree stands and ground blinds. Approximately 0.84 miles of established trail systems provide access for UTV and ATV riding, hiking, snowshoeing, cross-country skiing, and more.
Whether the house on the property is sufficient for your family or you want to build your dream home, the potential is there, and there are many spots that would make excellent potential building locations for a larger home. Consult the Town of Cochecton for all possibilities.
The opportunities don’t end with the property. The surrounding area has a lot to offer as well. Just minutes from the Delaware River, you’ll find opportunities for rafting, canoeing, fishing, or simply watching the bald eagles. Catch a show at Bethel Woods Center for the Arts or try your hand at gambling at Resorts World Catskills. Other local fishing opportunities can be found at Lake Huntington and Callicoon Creek. Many local restaurants in the area offer an amazing dining experience.
This 50+/- acre Sullivan County, New York tract offers frontage on two seasonally maintained roads, Stoney Road and Haase Road. The land features varied topography, rocky and moss-covered outcroppings, a stream, and a mixed hardwood forest with pockets of dense hemlock and scattered white pine. Vibrant ferns cover the forest floor in certain areas. A strong pick for hunting and recreation.
Long:
Tucked into the wooded hills of Sullivan County, New York, this 50+/- acre property delivers the kind of varied terrain and cover that serious hunters and outdoor enthusiasts look for in a recreational tract. With frontage on two seasonally maintained dirt roads, Stony Road and Haase Road, the property offers multiple points of access, a practical advantage for setting up separate entry and exit routes for different stand locations or seasons.
The topography across the acreage varies throughout, rising and falling in a way that creates natural funnels and travel corridors, features that whitetail deer and other wildlife rely on as they move through the landscape. Scattered throughout the property are rocky, moss-covered boulders and outcroppings, adding both visual character and structure to the terrain.
The forest cover is a mix of hardwoods with pockets of dense hemlock and scattered white pine woven throughout. This kind of habitat diversity gives wildlife both mast-producing hardwoods for feed and thick conifer along with marshy areas of dense vegetation for cover for bedding and protection from the elements, a combination that tends to hold deer and other game well through the fall and winter months. In certain areas, vibrant ferns blanket the forest floor, adding to the property’s natural character and giving it a distinct, established woodland feel.
Whether the goal is a dedicated hunting camp, a recreational retreat, or simply a private wooded holding in the Catskills region of New York, this Sullivan County acreage offers the terrain, water, cover, and access to support it. Sullivan County is well known among hunters and outdoor recreationists for its mix of public and private forestland, its trout streams, and its long tradition as a Catskills hunting and recreation destination.
The property is located just minutes from the Delaware River and Lake Huntington. Both of these provide opportunities for fishing. The area provides ample opportunities for dining and entertainment within a short drive.
The property has frontage on two roads, and both of these roads are considered seasonal, limited-use highways and are not maintained between December 1 and April 1. Electricity is not available on either of the roads in front of the property. There is an abandoned hunting camp on the property that is uninhabitable. The seller makes no representation or warranty regarding the condition of the structure.
Exciting new price! Experience a flawless lakeside retreat and drift into lake-life mode with this entirely rebuilt waterfront home set along the peaceful shoreline of Lake Huntington. This serene lake house is the perfect year-round escape. You can never get enough of the breathtaking, unobstructed water views and sunsets creating a seamless connection to nature. Completely renovated in 2025 and thoughtfully design for both comfort and style, the home showcases a range of distinctive details, including a cozy wood-burning stove, butcher block countertops, whitewashed maple wood flooring and reclaimed barn wood beams that beautifully define the different rooms of the open-concept living area. The house also comes equipped with a Mitsubishi mini split heating and cooling system. The stunning kitchen includes KraftMaid cabinetry, extensive countertop, solid brass hardware, floating shelves and a charming vintage built-in hutch. Designed to seamlessly blend modern comfort with relaxed lake-house charm. Flooded with natural light, the home offers three bright bedrooms, two full bathrooms, two dining areas perfect for gathering and a versatile bonus loft. The light-filled living room centers around the wood stove and is framed by walls of sliding doors that open to sweeping lake views, creating a warm and inviting space year-round. The cantilever wraparound deck offers an expansive outdoor space perfect for relaxing or hosting guests. The backyard leads directly to your private stretch of Lake Huntington, with a private dock for easy water access, ideal for boating enthusiasts to enjoy this peaceful motorboat lake. Just a short drive from New York City this property combines sophisticated design, serenity and uninterrupted lake views. Centrally situated near Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, home of the original 1969 Woodstock Festival, as well as the charming nearby towns of Narrowsburg, Callicoon, and Jeffersonville, known for their restaurants, shops and outdoor recreation. The home also offers easy access to scenic hiking trails and forest nature preserves. It is an ideal retreat for those seeking a refined balance of nature, culture and lakeside living. This property is well suited to use as a permanent residence year-round, a vacation home or as an investment property with the potential for short term rental. This home already has been a very successful STR.
Welcome to this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home, perfectly situated on over 2 private acres along a peaceful country road. Thoughtfully updated and designed with a spacious open-concept layout, this home offers comfortable living and effortless entertaining.
The bright, expansive floor plan seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas, creating an inviting atmosphere for family and guests alike. Step outside onto the deck and enjoy the tranquility of nature.
The property features generous front and back yards, providing ample space for outdoor gatherings, recreation, or simply relaxing in a serene setting. Mature trees and established fruit trees enhance the natural beauty and privacy of the grounds. There’s also an above ground pool to enjoy in the summer months.
Ideally located in the Town of Cochecton, this home offers the perfect balance of rural charm and convenience. Just minutes from the vibrant hamlets of Callicoon, Narrowsburg, Jeffersonville, Livingston Manor, and the renowned Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, you’ll enjoy easy access to dining, shopping, outdoor recreation, and cultural attractions.
Step back into two centuries of history at this remarkable 1820s home overlooking the beautiful Delaware River in Cochecton, NY. Rich with character, local lore and sweeping river views, this one-of-a kind property offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of the Upper Delaware River’s past. The home features 4 spacious bedrooms and a full bath upstairs. You’ll find the roomy living room, kitchen and large dining room on the main level. But its most fascinating feature is found on the lower level: the historic Valleau Tavern! Back in the days when logging was a major industry along the Delaware, logging men guiding rafts through the Big Bend in Cochecton would stop for food and lodging here while traveling downstream. Imagine the stories and pints that were slung here! It’s an incredible connection to the area’s storied past, more than 200 years later. (The Valleau Tavern even has its own Wikipedia page!) This area has the bar, 3 taps, a large open space with exposed joists and gorgeous wood floors. Plus, there’s an additional bathroom down here. Steps go out to the back of the home, where you’ll find incredible bluestone work. And a cool bragging right: the home is on the National and NYS Register of Historic Places. The property crosses Rt 97, so you have a piece of land on the river side with river views. The front porch is picturesque and welcoming. Sit a spell and watch the world go by! Or relax in the yard overlooking the river with terrific views… it’s a great place for bbqs! The owners have lovingly tended to lush plantings around the home, providing beauty and privacy. Incredible stonework sets it all off and pulls the setting together. There’s a 2-car garage for vehicles, lawn & river equipment or storage.. check out the lower level for even more room! The full attic is empty, and ready for you to finish it. This home is being offered fully furnished, tastefully designed by a former Ralph Lauren Interior Designer. Whether you choose this well-preserved home for its history or its terrific location (which is central to everything, including 5 minutes to Callicoon, 15 to Narrowsburg or Bethel Woods), you can be sure it’ll be more than a place to relax: it’s a place where countless memories have been made! Start making yours here too!
**Rare 79-Acre Catskills Estate Retreat | Family-Owned Legacy Property with Pond, Barn & Endless Possibilities**
A truly rare Catskills offering—79 private acres with a rich family history spanning over 68 years. This exceptional property provides the perfect opportunity to create a private estate, family compound, recreational retreat, or long-term land investment just two hours from New York City.
Comprised of two contiguous parcels totaling approximately 79 acres—29 acres in the Town of Delaware (SBL# 26.-1-45) and 50 acres in the Town of Cochecton (SBL# 2.-1-19)—the property features a beautiful mix of mature hardwood forest, open areas, varied terrain, and abundant wildlife. A spring-fed pond, established trails, and over 2,675 feet of road frontage provide privacy, accessibility, and exceptional potential.
Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the thoughtfully managed forest, including mature oak trees, apple trees, and a healthy ecosystem that attracts deer, turkey, and other wildlife. Existing hunting blinds and logging roads make this an ideal property for recreation, hunting, hiking, wildlife observation, or simply enjoying your own private Catskills sanctuary.
The diverse topography offers multiple potential homesites, including elevated areas with scenic mountain and valley views. A small barn with 100-amp underground electric service provides immediate functionality for storage, a workshop, or future recreational use.
With its extensive road frontage and flexible layout, the property also presents opportunities for a private family compound, multiple residences, or thoughtful future development. Large acreage parcels with this combination of privacy, water, infrastructure, and accessibility are increasingly rare.
Conveniently located near the Delaware River, Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, Resorts World Catskills, and the charming communities of Callicoon, Barryville, Eldred, Livingston Manor, and Bethel. Enjoy world-class fishing, kayaking, hiking, skiing, horseback riding, local farms, wineries, breweries, and everything the Catskills lifestyle has to offer.
The 50-acre parcel may qualify for forestry or conservation programs, offering potential tax benefits while preserving the property’s natural beauty and long-term value.
A rare opportunity to own a piece of the Catskills with history, privacy, recreation, and endless possibilities.
Just bring your belongings and settle in to this completely renovated single-story home just 7 miles west of Bethel Woods. Located in the western part of a Sullivan County with its natural beauty of rolling hills, farms and Delaware River to the west. This home is completely renovated with new heating system with A/C new electric, plumbing and insulation. Both the kitchen and bathroom are new as well. Surrounding all this newness is all charm of a stone fireplace and charming wood.
Welcome to the quaint and inviting hamlet of Fosterdale, that is just an eight minute ride to Bethel Woods Performing Arts Center. This spacious four bedroom home is set nicely off the road on 2+ acres. It features: an inground heated pool, fruit trees, many perennial flowers, and a fenced vegetable garden with raspberry bushes. There is also a paved driveway with plenty of parking space, a large basement with a workshop, and an extra room in the attic. Throughout the entire house there is ample closets and storage. One closet is cedar. A beautiful brick fireplace in the massive living room with vaulted ceilings only adds to the dramatic sense of comfort. An open floor plan in the kitchen and dining room has a wood stove for cozy fireside dining. A one car garage that has been transformed into a successful home business could easily be returned to a garage with a change of doors. An energy efficient Buderus furnace is in the basement that has a back up wood furnace (currently not connected) but could be utilized for alternative heating options, if needed. This home is close to schools, lakes, shopping, the Delaware River, restaurants and parks. If so desired, there are commercial possibilities to enable a live and work advantage.
