1 / 4 
A rare opportunity to own land in one of Fire Island’s most beloved communities. Fair Harbor offers a classic beach town feel with easy ocean and bay access, a tight-knit neighborhood vibe, and a strong summer rental market.
This is two separate parcels being sold together as one.
This property is on the east side of Fifth Avenue on the bay side.
| Listed | May 23, 2026 |
| Days on Market | 125 |
| Last Updated | July 20, 2026 |
Full public sale/price history isn't available through our listing feed for this property.
Drag the sliders above to model your own purchase price, term, down payment, and rate — the numbers update live. For a precise breakdown, use our NYC Buyer Closing Cost Calculator and Commission Rebate Calculator.
5th Avenue – For Sale
5th Avenue – For Sale
Due to recent rule changes, buyer agent commissions are no longer advertised on the MLS. NestApple estimates your rebate as up to 2% of the purchase price, based on our standard commission-sharing arrangement. Prior to any showing, we will confirm the exact commission and rebate amount with the listing agent and with you in writing. Commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. Listing information for this property is sourced via the REBNY RLS, which does not fix, control, recommend, suggest or maintain any commission rates and/or fees for services, and is not the source of any commission information.
Closed-sale data isn't available through our current listing feed for this neighborhood.
