1 / 19

Check out this historic 200-year-old site, hitting the property for the first time since its inception. The site features three connected buildings – Fellowship Hall (built 1824, seats 200, functional historic organ), Rectory (late 1800s, 3 stories) and Cafeteria (mid 1900s, full kitchen including Ansul hood system and ranges) – all heating by oil furnace and cooled with a combination of window and wall units. Many upgrades over the years – roof siding, furnace, paint, flooring. Sale also includes 4400 Albany Post Road (updated single-story 2,376SF retail/office building currently leased on flexible terms) and historic cemetery split between the two parcels.
Highest and best use is continued religious/institutional facility, mainly due to NYS requirements for maintenance of the graveyard in perpetuity.
| Listed | July 20, 2026 |
| Days on Market | 120 |
| Last Updated | October 25, 2026 |
Full public sale/price history isn't available through our listing feed for this property.
Drag the sliders above to model your own purchase price, term, down payment, and rate — the numbers update live. For a precise breakdown, use our NYC Buyer Closing Cost Calculator and Commission Rebate Calculator.
Closed-sale data isn't available through our current listing feed for this neighborhood.




